In Tribeca, a few blocks from the site of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, there is an abandoned, run down, five story building. It's gray facade speckled with dirt. Above the entrance and boarded up windows, the words "Burlington Coat Factory" are legible, outlined in grime that had collected around the edges of the solid block letters that have long since been removed. This less than spectacular site has, though a series of most unfortunate and truly disheartening events, become one of the most controversial places in America. Why? Because a local Islamic group based in Manhattan has bought the property, and plans to demolish it, replacing the old department store with a 13 story mosque and community center.
A mosque two blocks from ground zero. For most Americans, it is a notion that evokes one of two emotions... anger or apathy.
In recent weeks, this story has evolved from a local issue, into a national headline. Many Americans are passionately against this mosque being built, believing that it is insensitive, a disgrace to those who died in the 9-11 attacks. Others, both inside and outside of the Muslim community, support the building of the mosque, as a testament to the growth in tolerance and acceptance within America following the initial attacks. I will give you a few moments to gather your own opinion before I render mine.
**
The feelings held by both parties are valid, and to say otherwise would, itself, be insensitive, however, the real problems arise when we mix politics into the equation.
An issue that should have remained a local one has now found its way onto the national stage, and has begun pitting American against American... stirring up feelings of hate and contempt, and prompting an irrational response.
The fear and anger from 9/11/01 still resonates within each American. On that day, we lost control... we had no say over the direction of our country... over what happened in Arlington, VA, Shanksville, PA, and, most of all, in Lower Manhattan, but now we do, and so we seek to use this opportunity to enact some control over the fate of an area that each of us recognizes as sacred. Having control over this area is good, but it is how we choose to wield that control that can, and has, gotten us into trouble.
In the 1940s, following Pearl Harbor, our fears and desire for control caused us to take irrational steps to secure our safety... enter Japanese Internment Camps... forcing innocent Americans to leave their homes and live in tents in the California dessert.
Later, in the 1960s, McCarthyism spread like wildfire throughout the nation, as the height of the red scare had us looking over our shoulders at our coworkers, our neighbors, our friends, practically sniffing our communists like hounds on a fox hunt.
More recently, we have freedom fries... America's personal "up your's" to France for refusing to follow in our footsteps as we invaded the nation of Iraq. This past year, due to misinformation, we saw a faction rise that chastised anyone and everyone in support of healthcare reform as being "pro-death panel", just itching to pull the plug on grandma... and while this small group did not hold the views of any mainstream Americans, it's voice overpowered those speaking with legitimate concerns, and its off kilter message spread rapidly.
In these moments, we, as a nation, tend to get swept up into these small groups, these factions of extremism, without taking the time to think, to breathe, and to understand the full scope of things. It is not until years later that we experience an epiphany, like the first fleeting moments of lucidity following a drunken haze, during which we realize that we were not only wrong, but that we were, to be blunt, beside ourselves with ignorance.
We have come to a disturbing precipice in our nation's history. We have reached the point where we push the constitution aside in order to propel our own desires and agendas.
What must we think of our future when politicians like Sarah Palin, Eric Cantor, and Harry Reid proclaim that they are in favor of religious freedom, in favor of the first amendment to the Constitution of the United States, but not now, not this time, with this there is an exception.
Newt Gingrich, former speaker of the house and likely 2012 presidential candidate, not only likened those in the Islamic community working to build the mosque to Nazis, but also recently posted on his blog "there should be no mosque near Ground Zero in New York, so long as there are no churches or synagogues in Saudi Arabia." When has it become acceptable to (a) liken any American citizen to a Nazi and (b) put this great nation on the same level as the despotism we find in Saudi Arabia. Are we not better than that?As one reporter put it:
The entire point of America is that you can build a mosque near ground zero.
We are a nation of freedom. Completely, entirely, unabashedly. We do not turn people back because of their race, or their gender, or their age, or their disability... so why should we hinder the rights of 800,000 muslims who call New York City home, simply because we are uncomfortable? Why should we allow hateful ads to stream across websites proclaiming of the muslim community:
"And so, to celebrate the deaths of 3,000 Americans, they want to build a 13 story mosque right near ground zero."
Is this what we have resorted to? Is this the path we have chosen to take? Not simply belittling, but demonizing an entire group of people simply to have our own way?
As American's, we do not have the option of limiting free speech and religious freedom that is within the parameters of the constitution. As was proclaimed by the fill in host of the Rachel Maddow show, whose name escapes me, "I don't necessarily like Justin Bieber's music, but does that mean the government has a right to throw him in jail? No..."
Issues that conflict us, that concern us, that upset us have every right to be debated... however, a fine line must be drawn between debating about one's rights, and limiting one's rights. To say, as so many politicians have on this subject:
"Clearly they have the right to build it, but this is an emotional issue and should be looked at differently," is a complete and total abandonment of what makes this country great.
I am not saying you have to agree with, support, or even respect the location of the mosque, in fact I completely and utterly understand if you don't, but, this is America, and you DO have to recognize it.
Rights in this country are subjective, and the First Amendment to the Constitution that we founded this great nation on does not mince words. We The People (from the preamble, I know). WE hold these rights close to our heart, both respecting and admonishing the beauty and the opportunity held within each of those words.
At times, we must put aside what FEELS right, in order to do what IS right. We must look beyond our sorrow, and try to see that this beautiful, new 13 story building will look over Tribeca, not as an affront to the world changing event that took place 9 years ago, but as a symbol that we, as a people, overcame our adversities, and set aside our differences, to celebrate the fact that we are one nation, strong and united. A nation that, when forced to come together to overcome any odds, will neither waver, nor falter, nor fail. America truly is, and shall forever remain, a nation of peace, justice and equality for ALL people.